Through WM36 There are 90 WWF wrestlers with 5 and above cumulative stars for their careers. Here they are, the best big match wrestlers in Counterfactual history. Once I get to 100, I'll cut it off there. I'm breaking ties with an estimation of how many TV matches they would have had which were also 4 and above. I'm initally posting this after WM36, but will update this after each PPV, so hopefully, whenever you encounter this list, it's up to date (through SSlam '20)
Runners-up: 4 stars: Drew McIntyre Professor Woods, Bobby Roode, Mascara Dorada, Io Shirai, Becky Lynch, Truth Killings, Greg Valentine, Aguila, Raven, Tyson Kidd, Primo Colon, Dick Togo, Shane Douglas, Booker T, Billy Kidman, Mistico, Ted DiBiase, Terry Funk, Brian Kendrick, Dos Caras, Jr.
4.25 stars: Buddy Murphy, Akira Tozawa, Keith Lee, Kyle O'Reilly, Bobby Fish, Tommaso Ciampa, Matt Riddle, Walter, Ronda Rousey, Austin Aries, Barry Windham, Psychosys, Super Crazy, TJ Perkins, Spike Dudley, Doug Furnas, Phil LaFon, Juventud Guerrera, DLo Brown
4.5 stars: Chad Gable, Jason Jordan, Diesel
4.75 stars: Adam Cole
90. Low Ki (5 stars)
89. Apollo Crews (8 stars)
88. Ray Rougeau (8 stars, WWF Tag Champ)
87. Jacques Rougeau (8 stars, 2 Time WWF Tag Champ)
86. Matt Sydal (8 stars, IC Champ)
85. Bray Wyatt (8 stars, IC Champ)
84. Bayley (8 stars Women's Champ)
83. Sheamus (8 stars, 2 Time IC Champ, 2 Time Tag Champ)
82. Genichiro Tenryu (8.25 stars)
81. Pete Dunne (8.25 stars)
80. The Undertaker (8.25 stars, WWF Tag Champ)
79. Ken Shamrock (8.25 stars IC Champ)
78. Cedric Alexander (8.5 stars)
77. Charlie Haas (8.5 stars, 2 Time Tag Champ)
76. Dean Malenko (8.75 stars)
75. Kenta (9 stars Dark Ride Champ)
74. Jack Swagger (9 stars, WWF Tag Champ)
73. Jamie Noble (12 stars)
72. Hakushi (12 stars)
71. John Cena (12 stars, 2 Time Tag Champ)
70. Kingston (12 stars 3 Time Tag Champ)
69. Roddy Piper (12 stars 2 Time IC Champ, Tag Champ)
68. Charlotte Flair (12 stars, 2 Time Women's Champ)
67. Taka Michinoku (12.25 stars)
66. Lance Storm (12.25 stars, WWF Tag Champ)
65. Chavo Guerrero (12.25 stars, IC Champ, Tag Champ)
64. Tajiri (12.25 stars 2 Time IC Champ)
63. Asuka (12.25 stars, 2 Time Women's Champ)
62. The Rock (12.5 stars, IC Champ, 2 Time Tag Champ)
61. Langston (12.75 stars, 2 Time Tag Champ)
60. Ricochet (13.75 stars, IC Champ)
59. Sasha Banks (16 stars, 3 Time Women's Champ)
58. Luke Harper (16.25 stars, IC Champ)
57. Johnny Nitro (16.25 stars, IC Champ, NWA Champ)
56. Taz (16.25 stars, IC Champ, Tag Champ)
55. Rick Rude (16.25 stars, IC Champ, Tag Champ)
54. Ric Flair (16.25 stars, 2 Time WWF Champ, Tag Champ)
53. Tully Blanchard (16.5 stars, Tag Champ)
52. Fit Finlay (16.5 stars, IC Champ, NWA Champ)
51. Roman Reigns Uso (16.75 stars)
50. Dynamite Kid (16.75 stars, 2 Time WWF Champ)
49. Arn Anderson (20.5 stars, Tag Champ)
48. Sean Waltman (20.5 stars, IC Champ)
47. Kalisto (20.75 stars)
46. Paul London (21 stars)
45/44. The Revival (Dash/Dawson) (21 stars, Tag Champs)
43. Shelton Benjamin (21 stars WWF Champ, 4 Time Tag Champ)
42. Samoa Joe (21.25 stars WWF Champ, Dark Ride Champ)
41. Vader (21.5 stars, IC Champ)
40. DVon Dudley (21.75 stars, 2 time WWF Tag Champ)
39. Ricky Steamboat (22.25 stars, 2 Time WWF Champ)
38. Marty Jannetty (24.75 stars, 2 Time Tag Champ)
37. Hunter Hearst Helmsley-McMahon (25 stars, IC Champ, 2 Time Tag Champ)
36. Rob Van Dam (25.25 stars, 2 time IC Champ, 2 Time Tag Champ)
35. Shinsuke Nakamura (25.25 stars, WWF Champ, Dark Ride Champ)
34. Bubba Ray Dudley (26 stars, 2 Time WWF Tag Champ)
33. Matt Hardy (26.5 stars, 3 time WWF Tag Champ)
32. Pac/Neville (26.75 stars, 2 time WWF Tag Champ)
31-30. Usos (Jimmy/Jey) (29.25 stars, 2 Time WWF Tag Champs)
29. Dean Ambrose (29.5 stars, IC Champ, Tag Champ)
28. Razor Ramon (29.75 stars, 2 Time IC Champ, Tag Champ)
27. Prince Devitt (30 stars, IC Champ)
26. Steve Regal (34 stars, IC Champ)
The Top 25 is coming in June.
